Thanks for the very thoughtful and well written response J.Garrison. I think "messy" is a good word for it. I see this change as inevitable, but there are so many details to be worked through. In all honesty, I'm glad it's not my job to sort it all out! I think there are many battles to be had as this plays out, and the best outcome is probably one that is decided at the Federal level so all colleges and athletes end up operating under the same set of rules... whatever those rules may be.